(In the order the teams/contestants were drafted)

Ramiro:

1. Michael "Big Mike" Lynche

2. Aaron Kelly

3. Katie Stevens

4. Didi Benami

Melissa

1. Siobhan Magnus

2. Lee Dewyze

3. Andrew Garcia

4. Lacey Brown

Pebbles

1. Crystal Bowersox

2. Casey James

3. Paige Miles

4. Tim Urban